A Different Take on the Monogram

OK, as seen in the post below, the original inspiration card is in the middle. The one on the right was the first one I did, but I wanted to try it again with the other striped pattern from Dots & Dashes Designer Paper. Of course, I *love* the one on the left - looks more sophisticated to me. My daughter and her friend who is here spending the night both think the one on the right with the polka dots is better. What do you think?